The Green issue
Read more about: Climate Change, Energy, Green Party, Irish Election 2007, Irish Politics, Taxation
The publication of the Stern Report in the UK today has pushed the environment to centre-stage yet again, however it’s fair to say that the topic had been at the top of the agenda before this event anyway. In Britain, the green-shift in Tory focus under David Cameron has been the greatest evidence of this, something which has left a situation where all the main political parties there are at least talking seriously about the environment, even if little has actually been done to date.
The question for Ireland now is, with the impending election, what parties are going to move to greener fields in search of votes and, perhaps most interestingly, can the Green Party capitalise on an undoubted explosion in public awareness on all matters environmental?
In response to what Stern had to tell us, Minister for Environment, Dick Roche, said that the Government was committed to the emissions targets of the Kyoto Agreement, and cited the investment in transport as an example of this. Of course, the reality of life in Ireland seems to suggest that little, or even nothing, is actually being done about reaching these targets and as things stand we are certain to fail miserably in our attempts to reach these goals.
When it comes to day-to-day life and hard-legislation it can certainly seem as though the Government, besides producing some nice advertisements, is failing to actually tackle the issue for fear of upsetting somebody. For example, there’s the fact that you can only get a grant on renewable energy devices that provide heating, as opposed to electricity. This seems to be for no other reason than as a tool to protect the state-owned ESB. The idea of a carbon tax for motorists has also been rubbished, with the quite sensible suggestion of replacing road tax with a usage-based system not even being considered. Is that because most drivers are also eligible to vote? That’s a cynical way to look at things, but it makes sense to me.
So will any of this country’s parties, aside from the Greens, make the environment an election issue? Will any of them risk putting it centre stage of their manifesto, in a more substantial form than simply affirming the party’s commitment to Kyoto and renewables?
Then there’s the issue of the Green Party. Going by the heightened awareness on green issues across the country—and globe—the next election could be the best chance for the Greens to gather votes. Can the party get all those recyclers out there to vote for them or offer to make it easy for people to save on their rising energy bills by making renewable energy devices accessible? In other words, can the Greens get people who think green to vote Green? The reality is that, while perhaps unfairly, the Greens are seen as a single-issue party (it’s all in the name!) but they’re fortunate enough to find this issue is something of growing concern to the public from any background or industry and, with the right marketing, they can show people that tackling climate change isn’t about going without heating or paying extra for your car, it can be done with minimal interruption and perhaps even economic benefit.
Of course, should the Greens suddenly enjoy a surge in support based on environmental issues, you can be certain that the other parties will quickly steal their clothes. However, speaking from an apolitical point of view, that suits me fine; I don’t care what party implements practical environmental change as long as someone does.
Read also: WorldbyStorm’s piece on the issue of green in Irish politics; he’s of the opinion that the main parties will begin to take the rug from under the Greens very soon.
Head over to our T
oh I can hear them already, Dick Roche king of the wafflers leading, saying that its all hogwash
this country mainlines in ducking and diving always from what we should do
- i’m ready to be surprised to the contrary but i wont hold my breath
Interesting. I had very similar thoughts today as well in “When being right isn’t quite enough… The political mainstream, climate change and the Greens,” which I won’t post here as well since you’ve covered the same ground as well or better, but I can’t see their rising poll numbers as having any real relationship to the correctness of their analysis.
And I’m fairly sure that all the ideas Stern has come up with will ultimately be taken on by the ‘mainstream’ parties’…
Thanks for the link, WorldbyStorm, interesting read; threw the link into the piece to give another view on it, even though it’s not that different!
I do, however, think that the Greens are enjoying the surge on the back of heightened awareness, however once the other parties see the appeal in green issues, that’ll probably start to fade away again.
The fact is no other party seem to be talking green at all, besides basic and vague little references. As it stands I’d say the Greens could do better than double their seat share, especially when you factor PR into the system (where people voting FG, FF, Lab or PD give Green a 2nd preference), as being environmentally friendly tends to go above right and left divides, especially when they’re as centrist as they are in Ireland.
Couldn’t agree more. I think the centrist nature of the Irish Greens is crucial – possibly to their long term development.
As you pointed out in your own post WorldbyStorm the environmental issue is now mainstream. In Britian it is the new cause celeb for Labour, being seen as a flagship issue now that a report exists that highlights the economic consequences of NOT acting. For years the environmental issue relied on sentiment, the harm to flora and fauna, the ever encroaching coastline, flooding and of course, the jokes about unseasonal warmth (enjoying Bahama’s weather in Bray etc). It’s interesting that it’s now a hot political subject with all the parties in Ireland too. We had Fine Gael on the radio this morning arguing the toss with Dick Roach. But what the Greens can do now is keep all these sudden converts in check. In most cases, because Ireland was behind on meeting the expected targets for the Kyoto Protocol, (having relied on the excuse that Ireland’s economy was growing at a rapid rate in the last ten years) very little has actually been done and the plans that are in place are too ineffective to make up the difference. The Greens though have a chance of sponging up votes amongst those urban sophisticates (left, liberal, middle class) for whom the environment is a real issue, while steering clear of an prohibitive economic agenda except perhaps when it comes to making sacrifies with tangible environmental results.