Contact

Should we be covering something? Email us your ideas, rumours or comments.

Ryanair calls government’s bluff

Read more about: Agriculture and Rural, Connaught-Ulster, End of Shannon-Heathrow, Government, Munster, Northern Ireland, Transport, Travel & Tourism

What does a company do when a majority of its ownership wants to pursue a particular policy? This is the issue that Aer Lingus in theory faces with 50.3 percent of its ownership claiming that the Shannon-Heathrow route should be maintained. Thus the hot potato that Michael O’Leary has tossed towards the government.

The government owns 25.3 percent of Aer Lingus and Ryanair owns 25 percent, a legacy of its unsuccessful takeover bid for the company. [Denis O'Brien is sitting there with another few percent, by the way]. In this letter and statement, Ryanair has mischievously proposed to Bertie that the two large shareholders jointly request that Shannon-Heathrow be maintained.

Now the extent of O’Leary’s seriousness is perhaps evident in that most of the letter and statement accuses the government in general and Martin Cullen in particular of lying, in using the claim that a Ryanair-owned Aer Lingus would dump Shannon-Heathrow to argue against their bid, including to the European Commission (which blocked it).

The whole thing is such a tangled web at this point that one could find multiple motives for every partner in the affair. Does Ryanair just want Aer Lingus out of Aldergrove to keep its Belfast City service more lucrative? Is Aer Lingus looking for an all-Ireland monopoly on connections to long-haul flights (a business that Ryanair has little interest in) — something that the Irish and UK Competition regulators might want to sit down and talk about? And it was really envisaged when Aer Lingus got its Heathrow slots as the Republic of Ireland’s flag carrier, that these could be transferred outside the Republic of Ireland?

Finally, is this an issue that the voters in the West might have liked to know about before the last election?

13 Responses to “Ryanair calls government’s bluff”

  1. # Comment by Simon Aug 7th, 2007 20:08

    Ryanair don’t fly belfast London. So moving Heatrow slots would not effect them.

  2. # Comment by P O'Neill Aug 7th, 2007 20:08

    Ryanair is starting from Belfast City and so will be competing with an Aer Lingus hub at Aldergrove. In fact it’s a bit odd how close the 2 announcements were — as if one airline was looking to scoop the other.

  3. # Comment by Adam Maguire Aug 7th, 2007 21:08

    People were suggesting on Newstalk that Ryanair could move into Shannon and take the place of Aer Lingus’ Heathrow flights.

    I assume they’re not planning on doing that based on this letter.

    O’Leary is well known for being mischievousness but there’s plenty of method to his madness - like all good businessmen he won’t let his own rivalries get in the way of profit so there are probably plenty of good reasons for him doing this.

    It can probably be explained in a number of ways, for example him looking to protect his Belfast service, him figuring that there’s no profit to be made in replacing AL in Shannon and him also seeing a chance to both bash his rival, the Government and the EU while appearing to Joe Soap as the good guy in all of this.

  4. # Comment by Michael Cheung Aug 7th, 2007 21:08

    Michael O Leary is right to home in on this opportunity, whatever his motive, Shannon requires a direct link to LHR, whoewver the carrier, perhaps Shannon Airports should approach BA, Air France.co.uk or BMI to take a route.

  5. # Comment by P O'Neill Aug 7th, 2007 21:08

    Another thing occurs to me. Irish Aid (the aid section of the Department of Foreign Affairs) is being decentralised to Limerick. I thought that the one logic for that move was that they could still do all their necessary travel to recipient countries (mostly in Africa) from Shannon via the Heathrow connection.

  6. # Comment by Simon Aug 7th, 2007 23:08

    Your sure P. The website lists liverpool and 2 other places but not london from Belfast. Easyjet,BA and BMI baby fly that route

  7. # Comment by paig Aug 7th, 2007 23:08

    I WONDER WHAT THE DUBLIN WORKERS SHAREHOLDERS THINK OF THIS GREEDY POLICY?

  8. # Comment by P O'Neill Aug 7th, 2007 23:08

    The Ryanair flights are coming on 30th Oct

    http://www.rte.ie/business/2007/0725/ryanair.html

  9. # Comment by Simon Aug 8th, 2007 09:08

    ya but according to that they are going to Liverpool, East Midlands and Glasgow.

  10. # Comment by P O'Neill Aug 8th, 2007 14:08

    I suspect that O’Leary is looking at the other flights Aer Lingus is promising from Aldergrove — Barcelona, Geneva, Rome, Budapest, Malaga and Faro — and therefore thinking that there’s a second motive, of running a low-cost hub from Aldergrove that would compete with any expanded Ryanair service from Belfast City.

  11. # Comment by Simon Aug 8th, 2007 17:08

    possibly but he is already competing with easyjet there. Then again the less competition the better. With the workers Ryanair, the government probably own more then 55% of the company

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Aug 8th, 2007
  2. Sep 6th, 2007

Post a comment below:

Get Irish Election updates via email. Enter your email address:

Latest Links of Interest

  • Here’s the Dept of Finance statement issued late last evening about the Minister’s discussion with the banks.  I think we know why some banks didn’t want to be in the guarantee scheme: those in the scheme can be made an offer they can’t refuse: to merge.

    no comments » 29 Nov
  • Mary Harney’s expensive trip to Houston and Phoenix.

    The FAS/Florida row is not the only time the issue of her travel costs has arisen.

    no comments » 27 Nov
  • techPresident – The Future of Campaign Technology: The Ground Game

    Irish Parties looking at learning online and database lessons from Obama could do worse than bear this post in mind. Almost as soon as the election is over, improvements and evolution are making some parts redundant and others essential. Get your campaign an i-phone for everyone? Might be better than printing flyers, it goes to show how parties, if they take it seriously, need to keep ahead of the wave - not just follow.

    no comments » 10 Nov
  • Lisbon Is Doomed

    Colman at the EuroTrib give his reasoning on why Lisbon is dead. The Government's incapable handling of the budget cuts are the nail in the coffin.

    no comments » 7 Nov
  • Fine Gael’s Leo Varadkar offers his view on how the SBP Opinion Poll would translate in an election.

    no comments » 27 Oct

Links Feed Links Archives »