Contact

Should we be covering something? Email us your ideas, rumours or comments.

What if it was McDowell

Read more about: Immigration

Just listening to the Tom Mcgurk and someone made a point about the deportation of the Roma Gypsies.  If McDowell had been the person who had made the decision which most politicians would have made. People would be crucifying McDowell in the media. Yet Brian Lenihan does it and the media agrees with it.

3 Responses to “What if it was McDowell”

  1. # Comment by Adam Maguire Jul 27th, 2007 11:07

    I don’t think that’s true and it just feeds into the growing myth of McDowell being a misunderstood politician who couldn’t do wrong (but was always accused of it).

    Both men have different styles and that became apparent in this.

    Lenihan did his media appearances but stayed out of the general squabble - most importantly he waited until he could legally deport them. This meant he would avoid any credible legal challenges to his deportation orders, he gave at least the impression of considering what to do and not rushing into things and he avoided talk about re-working the existing legislation (even though doing this would deflect criticism away from him and to… wait for it… McDowell).

    You know as well as I do that McDowell wouldn’t have done this - he would have been far more prominent in the debate and would have allowed himself to become far more polarising on the issue. He probably would have waited just as long to deport them, but the difference is he would have spoken about his plans to do so straight away - this means that the media would be asking the same question for every day that followed until they were deported - “Why do we have to wait 3 months if they’re not entitled to jobs or welfare?”. Answering that would just put McDowell in a corner.

  2. # Comment by Niall Aug 2nd, 2007 01:08

    McDowell lived by the sword and died by it. Either he was totally incompetent, or he attempted to make himself the story time after time. McDowell Versus Drugs. McDowell Versus The Far Left. McDowell attacked by Green Party Supporters. McDowell Versus the IRA. McDowell versus Refugees.

    You’re probably right that there would have been a different reaction to the move, at least in certain quarters, if McDowell had been the minister, but that would have because of the approach he took to his job.

  3. # Comment by Henry Aug 3rd, 2007 10:08

    Niall, McDowell was brilliant at tackling asylum abuse in this country. He did more for the Irish people in this regard than any other minister for justice. Michael McDowell sent the bogus asylum cheats back to where they should have been deported when they came to this country hoping they’ll get a soft touch.

    The Irish left (composed mainly of cranks!) hated him so much because of this and they did anything they could to try to pull him down in the media. The majority of Irish people were actually on his side when he brought the Citizenship Referendum to end the abuse of the system by refugee spongers. Also, he didn’t loose out on the ground that you cited. He lost out because there was a resurgence of support for the main political parties like FF and FG at the expense of all of the smaller parties. Even the independents as well as your friend Higgins lost their seats because of this.

Post a comment below:

Get Irish Election updates via email. Enter your email address:

Latest Links of Interest

  • Here’s the Dept of Finance statement issued late last evening about the Minister’s discussion with the banks.  I think we know why some banks didn’t want to be in the guarantee scheme: those in the scheme can be made an offer they can’t refuse: to merge.

    no comments » 29 Nov
  • Mary Harney’s expensive trip to Houston and Phoenix.

    The FAS/Florida row is not the only time the issue of her travel costs has arisen.

    no comments » 27 Nov
  • techPresident – The Future of Campaign Technology: The Ground Game

    Irish Parties looking at learning online and database lessons from Obama could do worse than bear this post in mind. Almost as soon as the election is over, improvements and evolution are making some parts redundant and others essential. Get your campaign an i-phone for everyone? Might be better than printing flyers, it goes to show how parties, if they take it seriously, need to keep ahead of the wave - not just follow.

    no comments » 10 Nov
  • Lisbon Is Doomed

    Colman at the EuroTrib give his reasoning on why Lisbon is dead. The Government's incapable handling of the budget cuts are the nail in the coffin.

    no comments » 7 Nov
  • Fine Gael’s Leo Varadkar offers his view on how the SBP Opinion Poll would translate in an election.

    no comments » 27 Oct

Links Feed Links Archives »